Reliable insiders have disclosed that the question of engine equality will be featured in the upcoming F1 Commission assembly, set to occur at the Belgian Grand Prix next week.
The issue was raised following an investigation by the FIA into the present power unit’s performance, prompted by French manufacturer Alpine’s concerns that its Renault engine is not performing at the same level as its competitors.
Analyses suggest that the performance of various power units shows the Renault unit to be roughly 15-25Kw (20-33hp) behind its competitors. Neither Renault nor the FIA have officially commented on the matter.
Given the marginal performance differences among the teams currently, this power discrepancy could potentially impact the prospects of the Alpine team.
This situation proves particularly frustrating for Renault, as it cannot enhance its performance due to the existing engine freeze, effective till 2025, that imposes stringent constraints on power unit modifications.
The FIA’s technical regulations are clear that any alterations to the power units from this point forward must only be for the “sole purposes of reliability, safety, cost-saving, or minimal incidental changes.”
Nevertheless, the FIA, recognizing evidence of performance variances, is considering measures to help ensure fairness.
In the past, F1 has implemented engine equality during the 2007 V8 era to level the playing field after some manufacturers had leveraged reliability changes to enhance their own performance, gaining a competitive edge.
Ahead of the F1 engine freeze that took effect in 2022, it was determined that there would be no mechanism within the regulations to enable equalisation, believing that the performance was sufficiently close.
If the F1 Commission concludes that the matter of engine equality requires attention, it remains uncertain as to how this will be achieved. It is not guaranteed that Renault will have unrestricted authority to make improvements.
In 2009, a formal FIA investigation into potential engine disparity suggested that any equalisation efforts would be based on curbing the performance of top power units. However, no agreement was reached on the matter, which eventually became less pertinent.
Despite numerous appeals in recent years for turbo hybrid equalisation during periods when Mercedes led or Renault lagged, the FIA has yet to respond.
The F1 Commission meeting in Belgium will also cover several other critical issues, such as a potential tyre blanket ban and potential changes to the sprint race weekend format.
Also Read:
Alonso: New Pirelli F1 tyres have disadvantaged Aston Martin and Red Bull
Ricciardo “felt like myself again” in F1 qualifying return
Sainz “paid the price” for Hungary F1 tyre experiment
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) about Engine Equalisation in F1
What is the main issue to be addressed at the F1 Commission’s upcoming meeting?
The F1 Commission’s upcoming meeting will address the issue of engine equality, particularly in light of concerns raised by the French manufacturer Alpine that its Renault engine is not performing at the same level as its competitors.
What has triggered the debate over engine equalisation in F1?
The debate was triggered by an investigation conducted by the FIA into the performance of the current power units. Analyses suggest that the performance of various power units shows the Renault unit to be roughly 15-25Kw (20-33hp) behind its competitors.
What is the impact of the existing engine freeze on Renault’s ability to improve its engine performance?
The existing engine freeze, which is in place until 2025, imposes stringent constraints on power unit modifications. This situation is frustrating for Renault because it hampers the company’s ability to improve its performance to match its competitors.
What measures have been previously implemented to address engine disparity in F1?
In the past, F1 implemented engine equality during the 2007 V8 era to level the playing field. This was done after some manufacturers leveraged reliability changes to enhance their performance and gain a competitive edge.
What is the expected outcome of the F1 Commission meeting regarding engine equalisation?
If the F1 Commission agrees that engine equality requires attention, the method for achieving it remains uncertain. It is not guaranteed that Renault will be given unrestricted authority to make improvements. The outcome will depend on the discussions and decisions taken at the meeting.
Has the FIA responded to previous appeals for turbo hybrid equalisation?
Despite numerous appeals in recent years for turbo hybrid equalisation during periods when Mercedes led or Renault lagged, the FIA has yet to respond.
More about Engine Equalisation in F1
- F1’s engine freeze explained
- History of F1 engine regulations
- Alpine’s performance in recent races
- FIA’s technical regulations for F1
6 comments
if they do decide on equalisation, how’s it gonna work exactly? Seems like a mess waiting to happen…
Isn’t it about the skill of the driver at the end of the day? just wondering
Can’t believe Renault’s falling behind like this… hope they can turn it around.
honestly, not surprised. Alpine’s been struggling for a while now. engine freeze really isn’t helping them…
FIA’s gotta sort out these engine disparity issues fast, it’s ruining the competition 🙁
Ugh, not again with the engine equalisation talk! teams shud just up their game, instead of complaining…